Back to News
Fake fans, fake buzz? How your favourite band got big – podcast
EntertainmentMusicMusic News•May 5, 2026 at 3:00 AMNational

Fake fans, fake buzz? How your favourite band got big – podcast

By Presented by Nosheen Iqbal with Shaad D'Souza and Eamonn Forde; produced by Eleanor Biggs, Alex Atack and Rudi Zygadlo; excecutive producers Sami Kent and Homa Khaleeli•The Guardian Music

Shaad D’Souza explains how bands such as Geese have faced a backlash since a marketing company revealed its tricks for pushing them into the limelight, and Eamonn Forde discusses what it takes to succeed in the music industry today.Discovering new music you love can feel like unearthing treasure. So when fans flocked to Geese in the last year and made their frontman, Cameron Winter, the most talked-about indie star of the moment, it felt like a genuine rush of emotion and connection. They ruled the end-of-year lists. Their tours sold out. A big deal for a group whose members were barely born the last time New York bands were cool.But when fans heard a podcast interview with two marketing executives talking about how they created a buzz around the bands they worked with, a backlash ensued. The culture journalist Shaad D’Souza explains why music lovers felt so angry, and the music business and technology reporter Eamonn Forde tells Nosheen Iqbal why bands’ publicity machines feel they need to take such extreme tactics to break through. Continue reading...

Shaad D’Souza explains how bands such as Geese have faced a backlash since a marketing company revealed its tricks for pushing them into the limelight, and Eamonn Forde discusses what it takes to succeed in the music industry today.

Discovering new music you love can feel like unearthing treasure. So when fans flocked to Geese in the last year and made their frontman, Cameron Winter, the most talked-about indie star of the moment, it felt like a genuine rush of emotion and connection. They ruled the end-of-year lists. Their tours sold out. A big deal for a group whose members were barely born the last time New York bands were cool.

But when fans heard a podcast interview with two marketing executives talking about how they created a buzz around the bands they worked with, a backlash ensued. The culture journalist Shaad D’Souza explains why music lovers felt so angry, and the music business and technology reporter Eamonn Forde tells Nosheen Iqbal why bands’ publicity machines feel they need to take such extreme tactics to break through.

Continue reading...

Related News

Wendy’s shares new emo EP featuring members of Silverstein, Memphis May Fire and more
Music News

Wendy’s shares new emo EP featuring members of Silverstein, Memphis May Fire and more

Songs include ‘The Best Combo Meal on the Worst Night of My Life’ The post Wendy’s shares new emo EP featuring members...

NME Music News34 minutes ago
Sir Ranulph Fiennes' relatives tell BBC it's 'very painful' not being able to visit him
UK NewsEntertainmentMusic News

Sir Ranulph Fiennes' relatives tell BBC it's 'very painful' not being able to visit him

It has been alleged that Sir Ranulph has been admitted to a number of care homes under assumed names.

BBC Entertainment & Arts43 minutes ago
Johnny Marr on Fontaines D.C. and fighting “dodgy views”: “The current young generation are really switched on”
Music News

Johnny Marr on Fontaines D.C. and fighting “dodgy views”: “The current young generation are really switched on”

The guitar icon spoke to NME about new solo album 'The Age Of Everything', his love of The Cure, hope for the future, a...

NME Music News52 minutes ago
‘Legend Of Zelda’ 40th anniversary tour adds more dates
Music News

‘Legend Of Zelda’ 40th anniversary tour adds more dates

The orchestral run of shows kicks off in January 2027 The post ‘Legend Of Zelda’ 40th anniversary tour adds more dates...

NME Music News55 minutes ago
‘Futurama’ creator Matt Groening says the show isn’t over – despite finale airing this week
Music News

‘Futurama’ creator Matt Groening says the show isn’t over – despite finale airing this week

The show's current run came to an end last night (September 28) The post ‘Futurama’ creator Matt Groening says the show...

NME Music News57 minutes ago
La Roux announces 2027 ‘Old Flames’ tour in UK, Europe and North America
Music News

La Roux announces 2027 ‘Old Flames’ tour in UK, Europe and North America

"I can’t wait to get back on stage" The post La Roux announces 2027 ‘Old Flames’ tour in UK, Europe and North America a...

NME Music News59 minutes ago