Back to News
Troye Sivan: She’s the Best review – a strange, singular pop star who deserves to be multiplatinum
EntertainmentMusicMusic News•October 9, 2026 at 12:00 AMNational

Troye Sivan: She’s the Best review – a strange, singular pop star who deserves to be multiplatinum

By Alexis Petridis•The Guardian Music

(Interscope)Adored by the A-list and filling arenas, but without huge smash hits, the Australian singer treads his own distinctive path through pop via shoegaze, Balearic and the SmithsA few years back, the New York Times reported on the phenomenon of the “middle-class pop star”. The feature bluntly explained that this signified “a pop star who isn’t that popular”, for whom the word signified not commercial dominance, but “a sound, an aesthetic, an attitude”. It isn’t an entirely new phenomenon: you may recall a game late 00s attempt to differentiate critically acclaimed but commercially underground pop artists – Alphabeat, Frankmusik and the Clik Clik among them – from the massed ranks of chart-topping TV talent show graduates by grouping them together under the generic banner of “wonky pop”. But the arrival of social media clearly changed things dramatically, enabling artists who seldom, if ever, encroach on the charts’ upper reaches to develop ferociously loyal – and very online – followings, reliably packed-out shows and a genuine aura of celebrity to go with their good reviews.Troye Sivan might well be the apotheosis of this phenomenon. Over the last 12 years, his albums have shifted respectable, rather than earth-shattering quantities. Intermittently, the odd single has become a mainstream hit, but their success is vastly outstripped by his profile – arena tours, features in broadsheet newspapers and style magazines, interviews on late night US chatshows – and indeed his standing among huge stars. He has been glowingly written about in Time magazine by Kylie Minogue. Nicole Kidman appears in the video for the title track from She’s the Best. Madonna apparently gave personal approval for him to use a sample from 2000’s Music on another of the album’s singles, Party. He has duetted on hits by Dua Lipa, Ariana Grande and Charli xcx, with whom he co-headlined a US tour just after the release of Brat. Continue reading...

(Interscope)
Adored by the A-list and filling arenas, but without huge smash hits, the Australian singer treads his own distinctive path through pop via shoegaze, Balearic and the Smiths

A few years back, the New York Times reported on the phenomenon of the “middle-class pop star”. The feature bluntly explained that this signified “a pop star who isn’t that popular”, for whom the word signified not commercial dominance, but “a sound, an aesthetic, an attitude”. It isn’t an entirely new phenomenon: you may recall a game late 00s attempt to differentiate critically acclaimed but commercially underground pop artists – Alphabeat, Frankmusik and the Clik Clik among them – from the massed ranks of chart-topping TV talent show graduates by grouping them together under the generic banner of “wonky pop”. But the arrival of social media clearly changed things dramatically, enabling artists who seldom, if ever, encroach on the charts’ upper reaches to develop ferociously loyal – and very online – followings, reliably packed-out shows and a genuine aura of celebrity to go with their good reviews.

Troye Sivan might well be the apotheosis of this phenomenon. Over the last 12 years, his albums have shifted respectable, rather than earth-shattering quantities. Intermittently, the odd single has become a mainstream hit, but their success is vastly outstripped by his profile – arena tours, features in broadsheet newspapers and style magazines, interviews on late night US chatshows – and indeed his standing among huge stars. He has been glowingly written about in Time magazine by Kylie Minogue. Nicole Kidman appears in the video for the title track from She’s the Best. Madonna apparently gave personal approval for him to use a sample from 2000’s Music on another of the album’s singles, Party. He has duetted on hits by Dua Lipa, Ariana Grande and Charli xcx, with whom he co-headlined a US tour just after the release of Brat.

Continue reading...

Related News

Madra Salach announce debut album ‘Gorta’ with ominous single ‘Ribbon Factory’
Music News

Madra Salach announce debut album ‘Gorta’ with ominous single ‘Ribbon Factory’

“The ideas of longing and yearning, all the kinds of hunger, they slot into where we are as 21st century Irish people”...

NME Music News45 minutes ago
Video game Cyberpunk 2077 to get live-action movie adaptation
UK NewsEntertainmentMusic News

Video game Cyberpunk 2077 to get live-action movie adaptation

The smash hit from the studio behind The Witcher series is to be turned into a film by Paramount Pictures.

BBC Entertainment & Arts1 hour ago
Jessica Chastain’s ‘Other Mommy’ is a “hot mess” horror, say early reactions
Music News

Jessica Chastain’s ‘Other Mommy’ is a “hot mess” horror, say early reactions

Director Rob Savage has promised at least 50 jump scares The post Jessica Chastain’s ‘Other Mommy’ is a “hot mess” hor...

NME Music News1 hour ago
Instagram apologises for repeatedly suggesting Creed’s ‘Higher’ to “more people than intended”
Music News

Instagram apologises for repeatedly suggesting Creed’s ‘Higher’ to “more people than intended”

An Instagram spokesperson has said that while they are still unsure why it happened, they are working on a solution The...

NME Music News1 hour ago
Thom Yorke says he was already sick of ‘OK Computer’ and needed to “move on” by the time it was released
Music News

Thom Yorke says he was already sick of ‘OK Computer’ and needed to “move on” by the time it was released

“I wish I could do it for a long time. I can’t” The post Thom Yorke says he was already sick of ‘OK Computer’ and neede...

NME Music News2 hours ago
Cardi B shares playful new ‘Grand Theft Auto 6’ song ‘Don’t Chart’
Music News

Cardi B shares playful new ‘Grand Theft Auto 6’ song ‘Don’t Chart’

Fuerza Regida’s ‘Suzuki’ has also been shared from ‘Grand Theft Auto 6: The Album’ The post Cardi B shares playful new...

NME Music News2 hours ago